The armed forces special powers act, 1958, or afspa, as it is commonly known, has been a subject of intense discussion and debate. A cnn spokesman said as many as 980,000 people livestreamed the debate on, cnns mobile apps and apple tv. Make sure your class members understand how to properly organize their arguments, support with evidence, and anticipate counter arguments with this. We address the issues related to starting a debate society from a macro to a micro perspec tive.
As a part of the years curriculum and as an outgrowth of language arts, science, and social studies. On his visit to assam in 2006, prime minister manmohan singh assured the people of the northeast of replacing afspa by a more humane law. Furthermore the chair decides on points of order made and intervenes in case the code of conduct is not observed. A far greater blame lies on the centre and the respective state governments. Debate organizer graphic organizer for 5th 12th grade. For lincolndouglas and cx debate select default from the drop down menu. You have read 1 out of 20 free articles for the month. Repeatjlnq and ahienuing li1lli the lilomurablo dr. Douglas debated the slavery issue before audiences in different towns around the state.
Sir, i beg to move for leave to introduce a bill to repeal oramcncl ce. Manipur and armed forces special power act 1958 manohar. Oct 15, 2015 a cnn spokesman said as many as 980,000 people livestreamed the debate on, cnns mobile apps and apple tv. Guide to a typical ipda tournament click here to view this document provides an overview of the way a typical tournament functions, and provides clarification concerning much of the jargon one will encounter. The armed forces special powers act afspa owes its origins to an. Ihsfa state debate tournament 2017 team sweepstakes team 2p ld pf sc scpo wsd total place chesterton g 22 34 24 3 0 12 95 1 west lafayette h 12 26 24 2 0 10 74 2 munster debate x 20 10 10 6 0 6 52 3. People who advocate in favor of the law say that it is necessary to maintain law and order in the disturbed areas of the country, otherwise things will go haywire here. For decades, the armed forces special powers act afspa has enabled serious. A demonstration of the poverty of liberal imagination 31 pradip phanjoubam making good laws is the answer 33 civilise afspa 35 armed forces special powers actthe way ahead 38 umong sethi introduction 38. Talk about the theme of the round, the strongest couple arguments, and why the opposition has done a better job. Framework, when used correctly in pfd, really helps collapse the debate and allows youyour partner focus on what you deem important. There are some things, however, that all debate formats have in common.
Pdf the armed forces special powers act continues to be used by the indian. Afspa has been in force in the northeast and jammu and kashmir, and the draconian law has been the reason of wide protests. Im watching democratic congressman alan grayson debate republican congressman david jolly in florida. Open the event folder on the left and then rightclick on the round folder. The debate iso file selected episodes of presstvs the debate 1. International public debate association demonstration debate between orange coast colleges melia shumate and mt. Every kind of debate has two sides, but there are two general types of debates. Apr 30, 2016 international public debate association demonstration debate between orange coast colleges melia shumate and mt. Ppt debate powerpoint presentation free to download.
Debate from page 1 godspeed by ben humeniuk david poelariat staff george lopez answers questions thursday regarding the democratic debate held at the university of texas austin. It can open over 200 different types of files and very likely yours too. Below are documents to aid coachesprograms who may be new to academic debate andor new to the ipda format. The armed forces assam and manipur special powers act was signed into law in september 1958, and was later renamed the armed forces special powers act afspa. Violent clashes that took place in wake of burhan wanis encounter which claimed 23 lives and the supreme court taking cognizance of 1528 cases of alleged fake encounters involving army and police has once again triggered the debate whether armed forces special power act afspa implemented in various troubled zones in india is of any help or not. What was the genesis of the armed forces special powers act afspa. Afspa came into public debate during 1980s and this debate gained. Viewership hits record for a democratic debate ken walshs. Cover illustration by susan farrington write to us. Ihsfa state debate tournament 2017 team sweepstakes. Rewarding everyone on the team might make kids feel good, but.
Violent clashes that took place in wake of burhan wanis encounter which claimed 23 lives and the supreme court taking cognizance of 1528 cases of alleged fake encounters involving army and police has once again triggered the debate whether armed forces special power act afspa implemented in. I think people saw two leaders that share many values, but i think senator obamas message about bringing change wins the day. The suitability of afspa has been a matter of debate, with its serious complications and pros and cons. If using the student position handout, be sure to provide some time for completion of the initial position 3. Senate candidates are participating in an open debate where all questions were submitted and voted on by the public and moderators must ask topvoted questions. This debate organizer graphic organizer is suitable for 5th 12th grade. It does not waive or alter any of the terms of the policys. Now those last two words acknowledge creation require some parsing. Ihsfa state debate tournament 2017 team sweepstakes team 2p ld pf sc scpo wsd total place chesterton g 22 34 24 3 0 12 95 1 west lafayette h 12 26 24 2 0 10 74 2 munster debate x 20 10 10 6 0 6 52 3 penn p 10 2 12 1. A renewed debate in india the afspa facilitated sexual violence and extrajudicial executions. Debate training guide training debaters is a continual process.
Position sheet for describing their position before and after the debate, and for recording questions note. Afspa has been in force in the northeast and jammu and kashmir, and the draconian law. The recent developments in manipur have once again brought into focus the question of application of the armed forces special powers act 1958 afspa in northeast india. Explore new ways of thinking debate toolkit civic education working group 2016. However, certain sections of the civil society view afspa as a draconian act. The chair takes care of the time limits or, in a debate without time limit, makes sure both sides are equally heard. Therefore, this guide is to help you understand the most important features students need to understand to get started in debate.
Teachers guide to introducing debate in the classroom. Use the last couple minutes to look at the round more generally. As a unit of study, introducing debate skills with the process and information for the debate 2. Therefore, this guide is to help you understand the most important features students need to.
Speech and deba te union teachers guide to introducing debate in the classroom speech and deba te union page 3 of 29 pages generic debate format there are different types of debate and i t is important that you know what kind of debate yo u will be participati ng in. Indias controversial armed forces special powers act the. Indias controversial armed forces special powers act. For public forum select debate team points from the dropdown menu. Do you want to see india without jammu and kashmir, most of the north eastern states. Jun 27, 2018 debates are so much more than organized arguments. The debate started with a view from a patients perspective. As the us presidential campaign of 2016 draws closer to an end, hillary clinton and donald trump faced off at their third and final debate, moderated by.
The centre has done well to withdraw the armed forces special powers act afspa from the entire meghalaya state and restrict its operation to parts of arunachal pradesh. Lincolndouglas debate also called value debate is modeled after the namesake for the activity. In an illinois election of the mid1800s, abe lincoln and stephen a. For example, on the carbon tax topic earlier this year our con antitax case had a heavy econimportant fw. Some honourable members may have a feeling that per haps we will go on extending it beyond one year or even later. Jan geissler, director of the european cancer patient coalition ecpc, a federation of cancer patient and advocacy groups, who was affected by a rare form of leukaemia, explained how difficult it had been for him to find information about his condition. Ppt debate powerpoint presentation free to download id. Msda debate guide manitoba speech and debate association. Dec 11, 2011 the armed forces special powers act, 1958, or afspa, as it is commonly known, has been a subject of intense discussion and debate. On july 11, 2004, the alleged rape and killing of thanjam manorama, suspected to be a cadre of the peoples liberation army pla, sparked agitations throughout manipur for. Pace yourself carefully, and watch the time signals. From middle and high school level debate teams to collegiate level and debates in the political arena, debates come in all shapes and sizes. The republican debate in september drew 921,000 such viewers.
There is not enough time to adequately prepare students for everything they need to know in debate. The word creation is shorthand for the proposition that humankind was created by god in his own image as it says. Manipur experience contents foreword 3 with the torch bearers of manipur 5 1942 the armed forces special powers ordinance 17 1949 manipur administration order 19 1950 sardar patels letter to jawaharlal nehru 20 1958 indian parliamentary debate on afspa 1958 26 1958 the armed forces special powers act 30. If the constitution doesor can be interpreted to permit hate speech, then that doesnt make hate speech right it just means there is a loophole in madisons wording. Armed forces special powers act institute for defence.
Jul 12, 2016 here is all you need to know about afspa. A scoring checklist for the actual debate is provided for. All about afspa armed forces special powers act, 1958. Hillary clinton and donald trump engaged in an occasionally raw series of clashes on topics from trade policy to. That is certainly one style of debating the style discussed in this book.
Pdf on jan 1, 2014, adriaan bedner and others published debate find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Apr 25, 2018 the afspa is a draconian law that gives enormous discretionary powers to the armed forces over a civilian population. In simple terms, afspa imposes in the areas where situation of law and order is not under control of local police and central forces paramilitary forces. Viewership hits record for a democratic debate ken walsh. This debate aims to lay out the argument both for and against. As a society, we debate about almost everything from tax reform to mowing the lawn. January 1, 2016 this certificate describes the main features of the insurance.
I dont know what james madison thought about hate speech, or even thought about it all when he enshrined democratic discourse and debate. Before you cast your vote, i ask you to put aside your initial persuasion, and weigh up the relative merits as outlined below. The chair of the debate makes sure the debaters adhere to the rules of the debate. Debating tips and strategies there are many ways to structure a debate there are also different strategies for participating in debates, today, we will look at some of these strategies. The justice jeevan reddy committee, appointed for the same, recommended the complete repeal of afspa from the northeast. The republican candidates were in north charleston, s. But our official debate topic actually raises that issue only indirectly. The armed forces special powers act commonly known as afspa came in to force decades ago in the. Find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Recent events in indias restive northeast have turned the spotlight yet again on the armed forces special powers act afspa, a controversial piece of legislation that confers vast powers on. The afspa is a draconian law that gives enormous discretionary powers to the armed forces over a civilian population.
631 509 550 208 824 805 802 1271 869 750 389 1242 1004 1174 566 1294 173 1221 908 813 1313 1462 1016 964 1021 518 1492 346 467 1267 1462 1088 710 294 800 1176 1425 798 1293 1249 682 1416 1446 761 838 1119 1292 262